Completely disagree. You have to keep taking swings for a truly, franchise-altering QB prospect. Is that Williams? Is that Maye? Only time can tell, but you’re not going to get that by being risk-averse and sticking with Fields either - his body of work has been consistently below average as a passer. That’s all he’s capable of and we’ve seen enough in three years to make that determination.

https://www.statmuse.com/nfl/ask/justin-fields-career-fumbles

Why didn’t Fields audible out of what Getsy called and into something, anything that would have resulted in help on Hutchinson’s side? Like, even just telling the RB, come stand on this side and chip before you release for your route. I’m not an NFL quarterback, but this is stuff that even a decent Madden player recognizes lol

There is nothing a Caleb Williams or Drake Maye could do to elevate this team with all the holes and terrible coaching.

Okay, but that’s not the scenario being presented, right? The question is actually whether Caleb Williams or Drake Maye could elevate this team with a new coaching staff and additional resources, including another top-10 pick at a position of need.