• HelixDab@kbin.social
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    From a technical perspective, how much would an image need to be changed before the hash no longer matched? I’ve heard of people including junk .txt files in repacked and zipped pirated games, movies, etc., so that they aren’t automatically flagged for removal from file sharing sites.

    I am not a technical expert by any means, and I don’t even use Apple products, so this is just curiosity.

    • MisuseCase
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      1 year ago

      That’s a good question. First it’s important to understand that hash functions for pirated games or other programs are actually different from hash functions used to detect media like pictures, movies, and sound recordings.

      If you alter a piece of code or text from the original version the hashes will no longer match, but typically those hashes should match and some kind of alarm gets tripped if they don’t.

      With media files like music, movies, or pictures, it works the other way around. Detection tools are looking for something that is not necessarily an exact match, but a very close match, and when such a match is found, alarms get tripped (because it’s CSAM, or a copyright violation, or something like that).

      As to the techniques you mentioned for concealing a pirated game in a ZIP file with a bunch of junk TXT files, that’s not going to work. The reason it doesn’t work is that if you ZIP something, all that uses compression algorithms that change the contents of the ZIP file in predictable repeating patterns. It’s easy to detect and compensate for. Now, if you use your ZIP/compression tool to actually encrypt the file with a good algorithm and a strong password, that’s different, but then you don’t need to pack it with junk. (And distributing the password securely will be a problem.)

      Please, people who know more about hashing and media detection with hashing, let me know if I got something wrong, I probably did.