Stolen_Stolen_Valor [any]

  • 1 Post
  • 39 Comments
Joined 2 months ago
cake
Cake day: May 9th, 2024

help-circle









  • I apologize to once again to keep my bullshit going but to your point about Dutch’s characterization (which I think nails him to a tee) I think he was written a faux (some kind of) radical intentionally but not because of some lack of theory (but this could still also be true) but for both finishing up Arthur’s arc when he realizes he’s full of shit and setting his character up to make sense retroactively for RDR1 as a villain for Marston.


  • Does the debtor thing change over the game? I remember that incident early on being what gets him really thinking about who he is.

    Major spoilers for RDR2.

    spoiler

    The entirety of the debtor storyline pretty much sums up Arthur’s entire character arc. He loathes working for Muller Strauss in the (first?) collection mission he contracts the illness that eventually wakes him the fuck up. Over the course of the game when you accept missions from Muller, Arthur snipes at him over the nature of his work and grouses about having to be his attack dog. When he finds out he is dying, he starts wrestling with his mortality and with it his morality. This culminates with him giving Muller Strauss the boot from the camp. (Or I think outright killing him? It might be a decision I can’t remember.)

    My biggest criticism of the games writing is it saying “Arthur doing these shakedowns is the thing that literally kills him” It’s a bit too on the nose but overall the writing is great.



  • RDR2 is about a man realizing he and his ilk were sent by the American bourgeoisie to colonize land only to then have it stolen again from them in turn. It’s about the remorse from realizing you’ve been wrong your entire life, and desperately wishing to undo it. Arthur is scum, he even vocalizes this - he hates himself. He then realizes he does in fact, have a soul but if only too late.

    Most of this isn’t written explicitly which is why I would argue the writing is good, actually.

    Also you get to kill Klan members.