My porch light sometimes gets left on and annoys my very nice neighbor. It’s on a schedule but sometimes someone turns it on after the scheduled off time and forgets to turn it off. Is there a way to give her access to that switch only? I am using Kasa wifi switches and Alexa in the rest of the house. Thanks.
You must log in or register to comment.
Tell it every half hour to turn off… except the times it is supposed to be on.
Give you neighbor a scene switch connected to your Alexa that can control your light.
The neighbor could log in under your kasa account but would then have control over all devices in there. I wouldn’t have a problem with this. I share my account with my father. We randomly turn each others lights on and off. It’s fun
When we first got smart switches, I put one where my daughter Abby studies. I named it “piss abby” and when she was studying, I said “piss abby off” to shut the lights. She gave me a look and said “piss abby on” and kept studying.
Either add another schedule to sweep it off later at night or add a motion sensor for after hours.
While there are a lot of good suggestions tangential to your request, I think Kasa lights are tied to a cloud account. So, I think you could setup a cloud account for just that light. Put the app on her phone under that account. Tie just that one switch to that account. On your phone you would need to switch accounts to manage that device. I don’t know if you can tie multiple Kasa accounts to an Alexa, so you might lose that integration. Should take about 15 minutes of poking around to get it all to work, or prove it is a bad idea.
I highly recommend not giving your neighbor, however nice they may be now, control or the illusion of control in this situation. Situations change, either relationship-wise or otherwise. It’s best to resolve the actual issue, and not make a problem worse by fixing the annoyance to your neighbor, and/or fixing your automation to better suit both of your needs.
If your smart home has wireless devices (eg Zigbee) and your homes are fairly close, buy a wireless switch, set it up to turn the light off and give it to them?
You should make a secondary turn off time or max on time, I wouldn’t give access.
Kasa switches can be set to turn off automatically X minutes after being turned on.
Simple automation is your friend.
Trigger, light turns on for x minutes
Condition, between the hours of x & y
Action, turn the damn light off.Have an Alexa routinue that runs at midnight or 10pm or whatever and just turns everything off just in case. I have a few of those routinues set up to turn off my kids room lights, turn off their music, etc. etc. I have a bathroom light routinue that runs every hour all night to turn the lights off in case they get up in the night, use the bathroom and leave the light on.
If time between X:XX PM and Y:YY AM and light has been on for more than 15m —> turn light off.
“Also, if it’s bothering your neighbor, you may want to revisit the fixtures you’re using”
THIS - big time
light trespass is a major issue and illegal in most jurisdictions worldwide. In the UK it’s classified as a “statutory nuisance” and dealt with under the Environmental Protection Act 1990
OP needs to fix the throw of the light or risk his local authority (council) issuing an order which gets extremely expensive to ignore
Huh… wish I’d known that 5 years ago…
my neighbors never complained but i had flood lights on all corners of the house, pendant lighting for the front and back porch, sconce lighting by the overhead garage doors.
pretty shitty with a lot of light pollution in every direction…
swapped everything to dimmable recessed lights. much much better.
The only way to let her into your wifi switches is to let her into your wifi. Its too complicated to get them to learn it. Id say you rather just create 2-3 extra scheduled turn off times, so if it ever misses one turn off command, it will catch the next one.
The only way to let her into your wifi switches is to let her into your wifi
Totally incorrect. My father controls my lights from across the country using the Kasa app. He is just signed in under my name
Well … that does mean youre giving them access to any device connected to that account. There is no restrictive view that lets them control only 1 light
Isn’t there some sort of way you could create an alias of your email address that could be connected to triggering a light?
There are lots of good points here about preventing the annoyance to start with: better fixture/bulb/aiming, timer. Are you willing to cede control at a time when you may be expecting someone or put it on briefly so you can see?
I recommendcthese other approaches first. Why make your neighbor do something to remedy the problem?
Lots of other solutions provided, but to answer your question, yes, you can give them your kasa (or tapo) account log in information which would let them control all of your kasa/tapo stuff (including cameras if you have them).
You could create a separate kasa account, then reset your porch light kasa switch and join it to the new account. Then just share that account with your neighbour, she’ll be able to control it from her home wifi via remote access. You won’t be able to integrate the porch light with alexa or any other kasa devices on your main account once it’s separate.
Sure, but that’s the OP’s problem, not mine :)… Already lots of alternate suggestions to his problem, I didn’t need to pile on. When I checked the only answers close to what he ask was “no” which is wrong. A separate kasa account for this solves the problem. And it’s easy to reset the kasa to gain it back if the relationship sours since he has physical control of it.