I am looking for a fast USB drive which has a physical write-protect enable switch on it. I would also want a BadUSB-resistant USB controller. I want this for 2 reasons:

  • So I can diagnose issues on machines where the problem may or may not be malware. This way, I can plug it into several machines without risking spreading malware.

  • So I can carry around a TailsOS drive wherever I go, and use it on public computers and friend’s computers without risk of infection.

So far, I have only found one company making these things, Kanguru. There are almost no reviews of their products by reputable sources, at least not for their write-protecting drives.

Their BadUSB firmware detection module is NIST certified, which is great (given that you trust proprietary cryptography modules at all), but no certs for the main storage write protection. Also Kanguru products are very overpriced.

And no I am not using SD cards, their write protect implementation is software-based and they are too slow for me.

I am specifically looking at the Kanguru FlashTrust . My questions are:

  • Has anyone used Kanguru products and how was your experience?

  • Are there other companies that make decent quality drives with hardware write-protect switches? (Ideally ones that have FOSS firmware and are third-party tested, but I will take anything).

  • Are there any companies that make USB writeblockers which are small enough to fit in a wallet and <$50? (Example of one that is too big). That way I can use a standard, cheaper USB drive.

Oh how I wish Nitrokey made these!

  • anon2963OPEnglish
    2·
    2 months ago

    Thanks for the wonderful info. I think I will go with the iStorage datAshur PRO+C because it has the best speeds out of all of them. It is slightly more involved to activate read-only mode than a simple switch, but it should be negligible compared to the time to boot the system and other overhead.

    There is no way for me to verify how the write-protect works with this drive, but that is true for all of them, so I have to trust one. However, this company seems very competent. And importantly there are many 3rd party reviews of this and similar iStorage products. Also the firmware is supposedly signed so it should be immune to badUSB. But you do make the point that there is no way to be sure.

    I plan to use root on LUKS anyway (I want persistent storage), so I can keep / encrypted and checksum my /boot every boot to search for anomalies. Once LUKS is decrypted, theoretically malware could get embedded in there, but I feel like it would be unlikely for malware to infect one partition and not the other.

    I wonder if there is a way to setup a “honeypot” partition which holds no useful data but exhibits traits that are appealing for malwares to embed themselves in. It would be checksummed regularly while the system was running and alert me if anything changed.

    That open source flash drive looks awesome, and I will keep my eye on it, maybe I would consider it if my threat model was tougher.