-7DeadlyFetishesFascisms
As a former imperial troop… I don’t remember all of the citizens of Nazi Germany being marched into gas chambers after the USSR liberated Germany. It wouldn’t surprise me if there were far more Nazi troops immediately executed during the liberation, but I also don’t remember the entirety of the Nazi military being fed into wood chippers.
So yeah, as a dumbshit poor white trash 17 year old who signed up through the delayed entry program, I kinda have to support the “treat us as the Nazi’s were treated for their genocide” mindset.
Like Alaskaball pointed out extreme background checks on all US soldiers, draft or not, seeing the actively participated in war crimes and crimes against humanity in any and all of the past and present US wars and punishment accordingly should be the way. For the rest radicalization/re-education till they can recognize the error of their involvement and then actively being comrades is a good line to draw
This is better executed the closer to us the conflict is. For lets say Vietnam we cant do any such thing at this point but when talking active boots on the ground we do know that a a big chunk, likely a majority was involved in crimes against humanity and war crimes one way or another. And we do know that the vast vast vast majority doesnt regret em or has reconsidered and is proud , hell a big majority % of em voted for Trump and supported every subsequent war. So in this sense treating Vietnam vets as you would have treated nazi soldiers will have you be correct more than often than not
I mean yeah. Communists aren’t nazis. The USSR conducted extensive background checks on the soldiers of the nazi military to prosecute any war criminals for their crimes against humanity.
This isn’t saying there’s a clean nor permanently stained German military - it was shades on the slider. An example of this was that during the nazi campaign east in the “liebensraum” phase there were both SS and general army battalions engaged in genocide of entire villages. There was also a few battalions that either did not participate ( their commanders actually had a moral backbone). The Soviet investigation into nazi warcrimes would gather evidence of either case and make a judgment to either prosecute the soldiers involved or pardon them.
A more contemporary version would be looking into the service history of soldiers and seeing what careers they lead and their political associations are. An infantryman that was stationed in FOB bumfucksville Valley, Iraq where the most illegal thing he did was drink bootleg rotgut and work out the entire time and has no political associations as a dumb boot that checked out of politics to watch his team on Sundays would be considered pardonable whereas the logistics guy that spent his entire career counting the grooves on rifle handgrips and giving briefings to dipshit officers on the importance of not loosing equipment but has right-militia associations and is suspected of smuggling military equipment out to them would face further investigation and possibly prison if not execution depending on circumstances.
Making sweeping condemnations or pardons is not the communist way. Scientific examination of the evidence on all issues is.
Being a willing commander ,and too a lesser extend grunt ,on a genocidal and enslavement against an entire race of people war of aggression 2000 miles from home while civilian holocaust of tens of millions of people is happening around you perpetrated by 95% of your brothers in arms makes you indeed permanently stained and unclean. You dont have to rape women or execute every civilian you see.
There where shades on a slider but even in the outmost edges of it there certainly werent “clean” whermacht soldiers and commanders “with moral backbones”. Shades still started with almost black into pitch ,zero photon reflecting, black
Uh huh, I really don’t give a shit about this continual moral harping on over the fucking army of nazi germany.
I’ve made my point over and over that this is a discussion over how the Soviet union, after they liberated east germany, processed the surrendered German army to filter out war criminals and fascists from among their ranks in order to demoralize and reintegrate them without having to worry about a fascist uprising after the war with the above example as being a possible gauge for execution, imprisonment, reeducation, or reintegration.
If you want to discuss that then I’m down, but if you’re going to try to argue about what shade of vanta or coal or super or soot black you think best suits the nazis, then go argue with someone else.
:07: for coming around and winding up on the right side of things.
I didn’t enlist out of some patriotic duty or something, I was just poor and terrified about not being able to pay for college.
The Army experience was both horribly disappointing and enlightening in a bunch of different ways though.
The Soviets killed a bunch of Nazi soldiers after they were captured (fucking good) and put a lot more into their gulag system for 4-10 years where they either died or ended up reeducated. Nazi soldiers were not treated well, though said Nazis were trying to genocide all kinds of groups, including settler-colonizing Russia, and burned, raped, and pillaged their way to Stalingrad, so I’m not going to cry over them under any circumstances.
I’ve been reading up on the early days of the DDR military, and a lot of captured Wehrmacht got reeducated and made emergency police in the occupation zones while things got sorted. Like the Soviets showed mercy to nazi pawns more than I would be willing to.
what is this weird obsession with attacking another poster lol. the power of the state can force it’s subjects to fight it’s imperial wars, this is seen literally throughout history
The vast majority of troops in Vietnam volunteered to commit genocide.
Every single one of them could’ve taken a prison sentence, where they would not die, would not commit genocide, and would not see their friends die.
They went there because they are vermin Americans, and, like you, consider foreigners subhumans and their deaths an acceptable price.
You don’t understand, no one at the time could have possibly resisted the vietnam war.
I wonder if there was some kind of famous athlete who sacrificed his career so as not to go do some genocide.
