I have a character I’ve been playing for months named Ambrose Dayne who’s pretty explicitly Batman and nobody suspects a thing somehow.
When their god unjustly loved my characters brother more than him they had a falling out and after some very pointed arguments over a romantic rivalry at a later point my character killed his twin brother, for this, he was cast out by their god and marked with a sign of the fallen, making him a fallen Aasimar.
Kaidahn the Murderer doesn’t miss his brother Abelard, but their mother Evelyn and their father Adamund do.
Did you buy any chance go on to sire the first vampires?
😵
Throw a few goblins their way. Maybe a Rhino.
Drow Paladin?
Or step it up a notch. (And ya gotta wait until this comes up in conversation.)
Session 1: My Chaos Paladin tells party his goddess’ name is Beth.
Session 2: Find magic sword, name it Beth.
Session 3: Tell party my goddess wants to be called Kate now. (Chaotics, ya know?)
Session 4: Explain that the goddess is OK if I still call my sword Beth, but I should name the next one Kate.
Session 5: Utter a vow of enmity: “For Kate’s sake I stick my last Beth at thee!”
Send a couple of yochlols their way. That ought to get rid of his smitey sense. Lolth doesn’t take kindly to usurpers.