first off this picture quality is ass. i can’t even help you decide smfh 🤦🏽‍♂️

Always without

In my opinion the cover looks awful, makes it look like a vtech kids watch.

Thank you my peeps. Love you all for your honest feedback. Sorry for the bad pic quality.

It’s so awful man, please remove it especially if you have an ultra, hiding all the beautify of it + It has sapphire glass.

Not necessary and hideous

This is why I wanted the ultra 2 as a mechanic the titanium is very resilient and a case is not needed. Just slap a screen protector on and go. The screen protector is all scratched up but the case not a scratch.

Without. Looks like a child’s toy watch with it on.

I’ve seen some bad cases here, but this one is truly in a league of its own.

But to answer the actual question - without.

I’ve run with $2000 - $3000 mechanical watches without cases for decades. What is this compulsion to rubberise the crap out of a sub-$1000 watch?

Without for sure.

Without

Without.

without.

Apple Watch cases just look fucking stupid. Sorry. Remove it

I think you’ve got your answer… nobody said with… I’ll also say without. Just feel a bit bad you spent money on a case!