• SaltyBabySeal@alien.topB
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    The thing is that he is an absolutely fantastic coordinator. Top tier, best in class, offensive mind. He’s really, really good at that.

    I don’t know why specifically he isn’t translating to the head coaching world. Is it because he lacks the ability to manage what is very good at, while also managing the rest of the operations? Is it that he doesn’t build a relationship well with all of the players? Is it that his focus on the offense is primarily cerebral, whereas relationships with players, and building a team culture, is more soft-skills than choosing the perfect play at the right time?

    There are plenty of people who get promoted because they’re fantastic at their job but don’t make great managers. McDaniels seems like that guy. Sometimes it’s good to just be an individual contributor and recognize that you aren’t particularly at your best, or even happiest, when you’re managing a team of people.

    Where’s he gonna go next? Truth is, I wouldn’t mind seeing him here in SF as a coordinator working with Kyle Shanahan. If you combined McDaniels passing game with Shanahan’s running & playaction game - and that actually worked out - that would easily be the best offense the world has ever seen.

  • supes2k1@alien.topB
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    1 year ago

    I bought the hype in 2018 when the Colts were going to hire him. He spent several years rehabilitating his image, reputable people were vouching for him, etc. And I thought we could make it work with him, Ballard, and Luck.

    And then he pulled his 11th hour stunt, and it was clear to me that he’s not the kind of guy that should run a major operation.

    The Raiders have other challenges, so it’s probably not all on McDaniels, but yeah, he’s not a good HC.