That is very USA centric, so I dont know the background enough there. The argument i am trying to make is against the “there is no justification” part of your statement. A similar statement would be there is no justification to kill anybody ever. Sounds all good and valid, until shit hits the fan properly. If you read my question as “killing civillians is fine” then that is an incorrect interpretation.
I got no argument against this formulation. Unless of course someone would threaten to kill my family unless i press a button and then random people die and my family gets to live. Not self defense, not combatants. I’d press the shit out of it anyway.
The people that drop bombs on civilians are responsible for killing civilians.
The people who starve a population are responsible for starving a population.
Are you saying that people have the right to militarize parts of their own country? And doing that doesn’t justify murdering civilians? Sounds like you’ve switched to my side
Removed by mod
Do you know how to read?
What to do then in a situation where civilians are killing other civilians?
Its wrong for anyone to kill civilians, what are you talking about?
Civil war. When one group of civilians is going against another group of civilians.
Do you think that the union army or the Confederate army were civilians in the American civil war?
Civilians = non-combatants
If they’re engaging in warfare, they aren’t civilians
That is very USA centric, so I dont know the background enough there. The argument i am trying to make is against the “there is no justification” part of your statement. A similar statement would be there is no justification to kill anybody ever. Sounds all good and valid, until shit hits the fan properly. If you read my question as “killing civillians is fine” then that is an incorrect interpretation.
Killing should only be done in self defense. Dropping bombs on civilians is not self defense
I got no argument against this formulation. Unless of course someone would threaten to kill my family unless i press a button and then random people die and my family gets to live. Not self defense, not combatants. I’d press the shit out of it anyway.
Removed by mod
I bet the Geneva convention has a pretty objective definition.
Removed by mod
The people that drop bombs on civilians are responsible for killing civilians.
The people who starve a population are responsible for starving a population.
IT DOESN’T MATTER WHAT THE JUSTIFICATION IS
Removed by mod
Were the nazis justified in destroying the Warsaw ghetto because Jewish groups had militarized it?
Removed by mod
Are you saying that people have the right to militarize parts of their own country? And doing that doesn’t justify murdering civilians? Sounds like you’ve switched to my side
Removed by mod